If you’ve ever tuned your guitar perfectly at the open strings only to hear chords sound off
higher up the fretboard, you’re not imagining it.
This is one of the most common — and most frustrating — experiences for guitar players.
The good news is that it’s normal, explainable, and manageable.
This guide explains why guitars tend to drift sharp or flat as you move up the neck,
what factors cause it, and why it doesn’t mean your guitar is broken.
This article is part of the Electric Guitar Intonation & Tuning Accuracy Setup guide,
which explains how intonation fits into the full setup process after neck relief and action are set.
Open Strings Are Only One Reference Point
When you tune a guitar, you’re tuning the open string length —
from nut to bridge.
That sets pitch at one point only.
As soon as you fret a note:
-
The string length changes
-
The tension increases slightly
-
The pitch shifts
Intonation exists to compensate for these changes,
but it can’t remove them completely.
Fretting a String Always Changes Pitch
Pressing a string down to a fret doesn’t just shorten the string —
it also stretches it.
That stretching:
-
Increases tension
-
Pulls the note slightly sharp
-
Becomes more noticeable higher up the neck
The higher the fret, the more this effect shows up, especially on thicker strings.
This is one of the main reasons guitars drift out of tune as you move up the fretboard.
Action Height Plays a Bigger Role Than Most People Think
Higher action requires more downward pressure to fret notes.
More pressure means:
-
More string stretch
-
More pitch change
-
Notes that sound sharper than expected
Lower action reduces this effect, which is why action is always set before intonation.
This also explains why changing action can suddenly make intonation feel wrong —
even if nothing else was touched.
String Thickness and Stiffness Matter
Not all strings behave the same.
Thicker strings:
-
Resist bending more
-
Stretch differently when fretted
-
Often require more compensation
This is why saddles are staggered and why intonation settings vary string by string.
Changing string gauge almost always affects intonation behavior.
Equal Temperament Is a Compromise
Standard guitars use equal temperament,
a tuning system that spreads small pitch compromises evenly across all keys.
That means:
-
Some notes are always slightly off
-
Chords in certain positions reveal it more
-
Perfection is mathematically impossible
This isn’t a flaw — it’s how modern fretted instruments work.
Understanding this removes a lot of unnecessary frustration.
Why Chords Reveal Problems More Than Single Notes
Single notes can sound fine even when intonation is slightly off.
Chords, especially higher up the neck:
-
Stack multiple notes together
-
Amplify small pitch differences
-
Make tuning issues more obvious
That’s why many players notice intonation problems while playing music, not while tuning.
When “Out of Tune” Is Actually Acceptable
A guitar is in a healthy intonation range when:
-
Most chords sound balanced
-
Notes don’t drift obviously sharp or flat
-
The guitar feels predictable while playing
Minor deviations are normal and expected.
Chasing perfect tuner readings often creates more problems than it solves.
This Is Why Intonation Is the Final Step
All of these factors — fretting pressure, action, string behavior — feed into intonation.
That’s why intonation is adjusted last:
-
After neck relief
-
After action
-
After strings settle
It’s the final calibration, not the foundation.
What Comes Next?
Now that you understand why guitars go out of tune up the neck,
the next step is learning how intonation adjustments help compensate for these effects.
👉 Next: Intonation & Tuning Accuracy Setup
Final Thoughts…
Guitars don’t go out of tune up the neck because something is wrong.
They do it because of:
-
Physics
-
String behavior
-
Fretting mechanics
Understanding this makes setup calmer, expectations realistic,
and results far more satisfying.
GuitarCrafts is here to help you work with the instrument — not fight it.
🎸 Craft it. Play it. Own it. 🎸
Ready to take your guitar passion beyond the workbench?
See how I built GuitarCrafts.com using the training at Wealthy Affiliate — you can do the same.
Build Your First Website With Wealthy Affiliate (Free)
